Jump to content
The Dark Blues Dundee Football Club Unofficial Forum
  • Dave MacKay Would Have Stuck With Paul Hartley As Dundee Boss

    • By UWTB1893
    • 21st April 2017, 10:12 am
    • 251 views
    • 0 comments

    Dave Mackay believes Dundee would have been “better sticking with what they had” for their relegation battle.

    The former St Johnstone captain, who started his career at Dens Park, thought Paul Hartley would have kept his old club in the Premiership.

    And the fact that the Dark Blues have gone for a rookie manager to replace him has surprised the Stirling Albion boss.

    “I’m sure Dundee will still be fine but it is obviously a real concern being dragged into the bottom two,” he said.

    “Six weeks ago it looked as if they might have been the team to pip Partick Thistle for the final spot in the top six. But they have been on a terrible slide, losing seven in a row.

    “It can be difficult to get out of runs like that and obviously it has cost Paul Hartley his job.

    “The timing of the change was a surprise. They weren’t in a great situation but it wasn’t the end of the world. There are a lot of teams within touching distance. One win takes them out of second bottom spot.

    “It is difficult bringing anyone so late in the day. I think they’d have been better sticking with what they had with only five games left. Paul would probably have got them out of it.

    “But they are obviously hoping Neil brings something fresh to give them a lift but it is a gamble.”

    Mackay added: “Obviously Neil was a very experienced player and he has been watching Scottish football as a television pundit. He isn’t coming into the unknown.

    “It wouldn’t have been such a surprise if the appointment had been made at a different time of the season.

    “But normally clubs go for fire fighters and the tried and tested in these circumstances.

    “It might work a treat for Dundee but it’s certainly some challenge for Neil going into his first managerial post given the situation Dundee are in.

    “It was only natural people would question the appointment because Neil doesn’t have much managerial experience.

    “He was in training at St Johnstone keeping himself fit for a few months when Derek McInnes was manager.

    “I hope he does well. He is a nice guy, a great pro and I have a lot of time for Neil. And it is a good opportunity for a young Scottish manager.”

    Mackay will forever be remembered as Saints’ first Scottish Cup-winning skipper but seeing both Dundee clubs playing second tier football next season isn’t a scenario he would wish for.

    “It would be terrible for Dundee as a city if they had two clubs out of the Premiership,” he said. “It would be bad for Scottish football because they are both big clubs with big supports.

    “But as we have seen with Hibs, Hearts and Rangers, you aren’t too big to lose your place at the top level.

    “If a club isn’t good enough over the course of a season they don’t deserve to stay up.

    “And for teams going down now it is harder than ever to get back up. It’s not easy to bounce back right away.

    “From what I hear the Americans seem to be the type of people that are committed to the club. I don’t think they will cut and run if Dundee do go down.

    “They have put a lot of money in already and have plans for a training ground and potentially a stadium to take the club forward.”

    Source The Courier
    Sign in to follow this  

    User Feedback


    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Related Content

    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
       
      Hartley, who was sacked from his job at Dundee last season, is believed to be looking at taking Jimmy Boyle and James McPake to Falkirk.
      Boyle is our Head of Youth Development while McPake, who has been out of action since his injury against Dundee United back at the start of 2016, currently has his Uefa A coaching license.
       
    • TheDarkBlues
      By TheDarkBlues
      This 8 week block takes us to Christmas and all participants who sign up online will receive match ticket to watch Dundee at Dens in the Christmas holidays.
      Please see below for details. If you have any queries please email [email protected]
      CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP ONLINE

       
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      Robert Douglas, Barry Smith, Gary Harkins, Steven Milne and Peter MacDonald will pull on the Dark Blue top once more while our management team of Neil McCann and Graham Gartland will also make an appearance.

      Charlie Adams will once again will turn out for the Dee having previously done so back in 2014 for Julian Speroni’s testimonial in London.

      For St Johnstone, they will see former favourites such as Jody Morris, Danny Griffin, Frazer Wright, Darren Dods, John O’Neil, Martin Hardie, Allan Preston, Nathan Lowndes and Paul Sheerin.

      Kick Off: 7.30PM
      Admission: Adults - £15, Concessions (U16s and seniors) - £5

      Dundee fans will be accommodated in the North section of the Main Stand
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      With the Premiership season kicking off this Saturday at Dens against Ross County, we spoke to @jailender about the Staggies, his views on Billy McKay crossing the divide and how it’s felt to see his team go from playing in the Highland league to cementing their place in the Premiership.

      I'll ask what I've done with every other one of our guests so far. What made you become a Ross County fan?
      It’s an easy answer – They are my local team. I used to go periodically as a kid to their games when they were in the Highland League. I lived just down the road from Billy Ferries, who became a County legend in the late 80’s /early 90’s, and I used to travel with his Dad and brother to the games. I lived about 25 miles from Dingwall then, and couldn’t get to all the games

      When they were elected to the Scottish Football League I was that bit older and able to drive myself by then so I bought my first season ticket for that first season in the SFL.
      It's been some story for County since you joined the SFL/SPFL. Could you have ever imagined witnessing the success the club have had in such a short space of time?
      It has been a tremendous success story over the last 23 years. Even just being elected to the SFL was a success as at the time, the Inverness Franchise team were dead certs to be elected, and everyone else thought that the SFL would spread football around the country and take in a team from the Borders probably Gala Fairydean, so for both Highland teams to be elected was a surprise.
      Back then to think that 20 years later the club would be an established Premier League team and have won the League Cup was unthinkable, especially when you factor in that along the way the stadium pretty much also had to be built from scratch – something that very few other teams in the lower leagues have had to do.
      You've also managed to become a mainstay in the Premiership and will compete in this league for your 6th consecutive season. How does it feel to see the club cement their place in the top league?

      Being in the Premier league is nothing short of an honour. When you see some of the clubs that have failed to retain their Premier status over that same period, it makes you realise just exactly how well the club is doing.
      Each season fans expectations get bigger and bigger, but to be realistic County are punching well above their weight by being in the Premier League, and while some fans will want a top six finish, or to win one of the cups, a successful season for County is retaining their Premier League status – anything more is a bonus.

      Liam Boyce has been a thorn in many a clubs side the past few years and It seemed to feel like he scored against us in every visit. With him now sold, just how much of an impact will that have on the team?
      Liam Boyce will be a big loss to the club. He’s been the club’s top scorer for the last few seasons and he chipped in with 48% of our goals last season – so that is a huge gap to fill.
      Its more than his goals though, he was arguably one of the best footballing players at the club and his assists last season were largely forgotten because of the goals he scored.
      The responsibility will now fall on the rest of the team to chip in with goals. We’ve added Thomas Mikklesen and Billy Mckay to the team, hopefully they can form a partnership along with Craig Curran and Alex Schalk that will get the goals.
      Our other issue last season was that we needed to score at least two goals to get a point given that our defence wasn’t the best – early indications are we’ve tightened up at the back so hopefully we don’t need as many goals this season.

      We heard this week that Liam Boyce has suffered a knee injury at Burton Albion. I think it’s fair to say that the majority of County fans feel for him as they wanted him to succeed there just to prove how good the Scottish league actually is.
      Billy McKay eh? Inverness fans weren't too happy when he signed for you but how did County supporters take to the news?
      The news Billy Mckay signed wasn’t the biggest shock to County fans as it had been rumoured locally for a few weeks before.  As for how the fans took the news, it was more of a “get it up ya” to the Inverness fans than a shock at signing one of their players.
      Over the years plenty of players have gone both ways over the Kessock Bridge, with the most notable being “Mr Caley” Ross Tokely signing, so fans are used to their players coming here.
      But in fairness if Billy Mckay scores as often for us as he did against us then he’ll soon win over the County fans.

      How have the other new signings fared so far in pre-season and the League Cup?
      It’s been hard to gauge the signings as most of our games have been against lower league opposition.
      Sean Kelly at left back looks to be a good addition, and fills what was one of our weaker areas last season.  As mentioned before Thomas Mikklesen has joined as a striker and with people comparing him to Liam Boyce he is always going to struggle to be seen as a success unless he can match Boyce’s scoring feats.
      Midfield still seems to be a problem area for us. Jim O’Brien joining after being on loan last season is a good bit of business, but I still think we need a “thug” type of player in there – we’re sometimes too nice and get overrun by other teams!
      Can you tell us one player that Dundee should be weary of? Also, if you were able to pick a player from our team that would make the County team, who would it be?

      Once fit I think Billy Mckay will be seen as the main threat to any team we face, although I think the main driving force behind County this season will be Jim O’Brien – if you stop him playing you’ll probably stop us playing.
      Although Michael Gardyne has looked impressive in pre-season and always has the ability play that pass that will carve open any defence.
      As for what Dundee player I’d take at County – Sofien Moussa seems to have hit the ground running during the pre-season and league cup matches, so I’d have to say him

      What targets should the club be setting for the League and cup competitions this season?
      I touched on this earlier but I think being realistic, surviving in the Premier League has to be the main target. The league is probably the strongest it has been for many years.  Hopefully we’ll not have the nervous end to the season and maybe a 7th place can be achieved again.
      Cups are probably our best chance of success, without trying to belittle the achievements of teams who win cups, but it really is just a case of winning five or six games, and in a one off situation we are capable of winning any game.  It all depends on the luck of the draw as well, but cups runs are nice, so hopefully quarter or semi-finals this season.
      We face a rerun of the same opening day match last year but at the opposite venue. What's your prediction for this?
      Hopefully we do better than we did in last season’s opener where we were well and truly beaten.
      We do look better prepared this season than what we were 12 months ago, but Dens park is never an easy place to visit – I wouldn’t be surprised if it ends in a 1-1 draw.
      I think we can all agree that Celtic will win this league but who do you think will finish second, eleventh and twelfth?

      I agree Celtic will probably win the league, but not as easy as they did last season
      Second place is going to be tight, but I actually think Rangers will edge out Aberdeen for second place.
      11th Place - I think will be Kilmarnock
      12th Place – Everyone’s underdog I suspect and go for Hamilton.
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      This coming Wednesday sees both clubs fighting it out for a place in the Betfred League Cup Quarter Final at Dens.
      We managed to catch up again with @DabChat to give his perspective from the other side of the street.
      United got their League campaign off to a flyer on Saturday with a 1-0 victory over Inverness Caley Thistle. How did they team preform? 
      Yes it was a great start against one of the teams who are expected to challenge and away from home. We played some good stuff but it was clear we were still lacking. No recognised striker until Keatings came on and a few players who would have played suspended so all pleasing.
      Last week saw Cammy Bell leave the club though not before some light hearted ribbing about the tweet that the club sent out. Will he be a loss for the squad?
      Yes Cammy is away, it was clear him and his agent were trying to force a move and who can blame him. 4 hours travelling a day just to train is not ideal. I am pleased with how the club handled it, this it was announced on Twitter is rubbish, it was on the club website to let the fans know the situation. It's all been blown out of proportion but the facts remain. The boy wanted away, the club posted letting the fans know they would listen to offers.
      Personally I felt he was overrated. Consistently let the defence down by not coming for crosses and it cost us in big games. The young lad Lewis from Southampton has looked good so far so all good.
      The Fraser Fyvie saga then drew to a close and he signed up to be a Dundee United player. What will he add to your midfield?
      Fyvie is a player I've rated for a long time and am delighted we finally got the deal done.
      A box to box midfielder who can pass and create. Fyvie, Briels, Stanton, Flood and Allardice We now have depth in that area and Ray can now pick and choose which games he has to play Flood. Last season he was overplayed in my opinion and ended up burnt out, losing form at the business end of the season, so that wasn't ideal.
      The first Dundee Derby ended in a 1-1 draw with United taking the bonus point in a 4-3 penalty shout-out win. How did it feel to see the return of these games?
      The last Derby was class. A great build up, quality atmosphere and ultimately an entertaining game. You just need to look at the attendance to see what it means to the fans.
      With your season ticket sales reportedly struggling ,another Derby so soon will be a welcome bonus financially for both sides.
      You finished top of Group C to win the right to be the seeded team and then were drawn against us again at Dens Park. Were you happy with this draw?
      I like the new cup set up however the one grumble would be around the seeding for the draw.
      It would make more sense for the seeded teams to play at home, that way if you do well in your group you get rewarded. Either that or you can't draw the other team that came out of your group would also make sense.
      With Dundee being beat at the weekend and the way United have started their campaign, along with their form in the League Cup, will confidence be riding high at Tannadice that they can claim the victory and a place in the Quarter Finals on Wednesday night?
      We should be confident. Ray has put together a very capable squad and in my opinion, a far better looking squad than the team that got us relegated a couple of years ago.
      It's a Derby though so confidence means very little. It's all about who wants it most, which team wins the individual battles and ultimately which team takes their chances.
      You just need to look at the last game. You's dominated for large parts of the game but still never created that many clear cut chances.
      You played without a recognised striker in our last meeting but will you be hopeful that James Keating and Scott McDonald will fit enough to make this game?
      Hearing that all three strikers trained today, Keatings, McDonald and Nkoyi, so that's fantastic news. I'd expect none of them will be fit enough to play the full 90 so I'd expect Keatings to start and get 50-60 mins and McDonald to come on from the bench for the final 30.
      Not only is that great for our striking options but also in terms of getting McMullan back to his preferred wide position. Let's hope he gives young Kerr a torrid time.
      Paul McMullan showed he was a threat against us last time. Even though we struggled at times to create one ourselves, what player would you be keeping an eye out for on Wednesday?
      Heard big Moussa took a sore one at the weekend, that could be a blessing in disguise for your lot.
      He didn't impress versus us in the last game. In fact, he made it very easy for big Edge and Durnan to play against him. They relish fighting high balls and the physical challenge. It's when teams get the ball down and turn them that they struggle.
      The one player who did catch the eye was the fast winger Deacon. You can see how he ended up on Arsenals books. He got at Scobbie all game but fortunately for us, his end product wasn't the best. If he gets that right this week, he could end up having a big say in the match outcome.
      For us, I'm hoping that with Keatings starting  and McMullan wide, this allows us to start Frasier in the hole.
      He gets a tough time from our own fans but the boy has bags of ability, can end up being the match winner with his trickery and hopefully get some of the boo boys off his case.
      Who do you think will proceed from the other League Cup ties?
      Celtic will cruise past Killie, Livi to cause an upset away against Falkirk, Hibs with a  comfortable win, Thistle on pens, Aberdeen will beat Hamilton, Rangers in extra time, Ross County home win.
      Oh and of course the Dabs to progress. It may go to pens again though.

About Us

The Dark Blues

The unofficial forum of Dundee Football Club! Follow us for News, light hearted banter or the more serious discussions regarding the Mighty Dee!

Recent Tweets

×