• Sign in to follow this  
    Followers 0

    Dave Mackay Would Have Stuck With Paul Hartley As Dundee Boss

    By UWTB1893

    Dave Mackay believes Dundee would have been “better sticking with what they had” for their relegation battle.

    The former St Johnstone captain, who started his career at Dens Park, thought Paul Hartley would have kept his old club in the Premiership.

    And the fact that the Dark Blues have gone for a rookie manager to replace him has surprised the Stirling Albion boss.

    “I’m sure Dundee will still be fine but it is obviously a real concern being dragged into the bottom two,” he said.

    “Six weeks ago it looked as if they might have been the team to pip Partick Thistle for the final spot in the top six. But they have been on a terrible slide, losing seven in a row.

    “It can be difficult to get out of runs like that and obviously it has cost Paul Hartley his job.

    “The timing of the change was a surprise. They weren’t in a great situation but it wasn’t the end of the world. There are a lot of teams within touching distance. One win takes them out of second bottom spot.

    “It is difficult bringing anyone so late in the day. I think they’d have been better sticking with what they had with only five games left. Paul would probably have got them out of it.

    “But they are obviously hoping Neil brings something fresh to give them a lift but it is a gamble.”

    Mackay added: “Obviously Neil was a very experienced player and he has been watching Scottish football as a television pundit. He isn’t coming into the unknown.

    “It wouldn’t have been such a surprise if the appointment had been made at a different time of the season.

    “But normally clubs go for fire fighters and the tried and tested in these circumstances.

    “It might work a treat for Dundee but it’s certainly some challenge for Neil going into his first managerial post given the situation Dundee are in.

    “It was only natural people would question the appointment because Neil doesn’t have much managerial experience.

    “He was in training at St Johnstone keeping himself fit for a few months when Derek McInnes was manager.

    “I hope he does well. He is a nice guy, a great pro and I have a lot of time for Neil. And it is a good opportunity for a young Scottish manager.”

    Mackay will forever be remembered as Saints’ first Scottish Cup-winning skipper but seeing both Dundee clubs playing second tier football next season isn’t a scenario he would wish for.

    “It would be terrible for Dundee as a city if they had two clubs out of the Premiership,” he said. “It would be bad for Scottish football because they are both big clubs with big supports.

    “But as we have seen with Hibs, Hearts and Rangers, you aren’t too big to lose your place at the top level.

    “If a club isn’t good enough over the course of a season they don’t deserve to stay up.

    “And for teams going down now it is harder than ever to get back up. It’s not easy to bounce back right away.

    “From what I hear the Americans seem to be the type of people that are committed to the club. I don’t think they will cut and run if Dundee do go down.

    “They have put a lot of money in already and have plans for a training ground and potentially a stadium to take the club forward.”

    Source: The Courier
    Sign in to follow this  
    Followers 0

    User Feedback


    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.


    Sign In Now

  • Categories

  • Related Content

    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      And the former Dee favourite reckons the rookie boss can be their saviour again after answering another SOS from Tayside.
      Plenty of heroes were created during the ‘Deefiant’ campaign in 2010/11, as Barry Smith’s side somehow recovered from a 25-point deduction, swathing budget cuts and a signing embargo to retain their Championship status.
      However, the fairytale intervention by McCann that season was something special. At 36 years of age, having been retired for three years and already a pundit with Sky, he returned as a trialist in a league match against Raith Rovers – and scored a 90th-minute winner.
      Irvine still recalls the wild celebrations that followed the strike and reckons it summed up their great escape – a spirit which Dundee would do well to rediscover, with five games to salvage their top-flight status.
      He smiled: “When anyone asks me about my memories of Dundee, that is one that always springs to mind. It was such a difficult season, we were pulling trialists in from everywhere because of the signing embargo, and he actually came out of retirement just to help us out.
      “We were struggling to make up the numbers some weeks, and Neilly came in, despite having his work with Sky.
      “He was great in training, really fit and then he came on as a substitute and scored a wee looping goal against Raith – you couldn’t write it.
      “He took off towards the supporters and the whole place went wild, the celebrations were unreal. Everyone just piled on top of Neil!
      “I’ve been lucky enough to win leagues with Dundee, but that moment stands out because it just summed up how hard that season was – needing someone to come out of retirement – but how we somehow found a way to get over the line.”
      Irvine believes that decision to dust off his boots illustrated McCann’s love for Dundee, for whom he starred between 1992 and 1996, and has no doubt that will give him a burning desire to succeed after taking the top job on an interim basis.
      Irvine added: “It’s a tricky job for anyone going in there and, given Neil has a good gig at Sky, it would have been easy for him to say no. For the second time now, Dundee have come calling and he has said yes without hesitation.
      “That speaks volumes for the passion he has for the club and I’m sure he’ll be getting that across to the players.”
      While swapping the TV studios for the dugout may seem a left-field move – and proved an ill-fated one when Gary Neville joined Valencia – Irvine reckons McCann’s punditry pedigree will actually be a massive positive.
      Irvine, himself eyeing another escape from the drop with St Mirren, added: “He knows the game inside-out from his work with Sky, he knows the oppositions and can go straight in there with fresh ideas, while already knowing the club itself.
      “He is a great character and his knowledge of the game is second to none. Hopefully he gets the right reaction and they get out of that mess because, just like Neil, I still have a lot of affection for Dundee.”
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      And, in the wake of seven straight defeats that have plunged Dundee down to the relegation play-off place, he accepts he should be.
      But the Canadian international has assured Dark Blues fans every member of the squad is fighting tooth and nail to get to safety.
      It’s been a horrific time for Haber and his team-mates as they’ve gone from top-six contenders to the side pundits are tipping for the drop.
      The board, though, have taken measures they think will prevent that by bringing in McCann.
      For Haber, despite the disappointment of seeing Hartley lose his job, it’s a case of all hands to the pump to help McCann keep the club in the division.
      “Everyone is committed to the cause, everyone is fighting for the team and the club. That’s never going to change,” said the 27-year-old.
      “Right now it’s all about sticking to what we know we’re capable of and trying to get results to turn things round. We know we can do that and we will.”
      He takes strength from the fact when he signed up at Dens back in October, initially on a short-term contract that’s since become a two-year deal, the team were bottom of the table.
      That situation worsened when Dundee went down 2-0 to Partick on his debut but there followed an immediate and impressive recovery that got the team back into mid-table by the turn of the year.
      And while the current horrible run of defeats has seen them plummet back down to second bottom, he believes another comeback is on the cards during the post-split fixtures.
      “We’ve shown we can beat most teams in this league and put together a run of results.
      “We have the players to do that, for sure. It’s about getting the majority of the team playing well again and we can do that.
      “Right now we might lack a bit of confidence, that’s normal from these types of results we’ve had. But we need to stick together as a group and we should be OK.”
      During this run the emphasis has been on putting each defeat behind them as quickly as possible and focusing on the next game but Haber concedes the players have to learn from the mistakes that have been made over the last month-and-a-half.
      And he doesn’t disguise the feeling of frustration over what is a self-inflicted crisis.
      “I think you look at the individual mistakes and collectively you have to look at the 90 minutes of each game and see where we need to improve.
      “There will always be incidences throughout the 90 minutes that can change the course of the game and you need to look at that bigger picture and work on those areas.
      “On Saturday against Hamilton we came into the game confident and to try to take some points, so we were disappointed with the result and how we conceded the goals as well.
      “Giving away a penalty is hard to take and the late goal from a set-piece was disappointing, too.
      “We’d set up in a way of playing because we wanted to be more attacking, especially at home and create more chances.
      “We started the game decent, had a few half-chances, got into some good areas but it just didn’t work for us.
      “It’s a game of inches. It just takes that extra bit of quality in the final third, that bit of class, and I think that’s what we’re lacking right now.”
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      Alex D'Acol and Mikey Devlin both scored for Hamilton as they beat Dundee 2-0 at Dens Park in the SPFL Ladbrokes Premiership as the battle to beat the drop intensified. Defeat for Dundee was their seventh in a row as they slipped into the relegation playoff place.
    • UWTB1893
      By UWTB1893
      Firstly, we suffered a record seventh consecutive defeat at the hands of fellow strugglers Hamilton at Dens which was a shocking performance from the team overall. There was no fight nor did it look like there was any desire from the players except for a chosen few.
      Secondly, we slipped down to eleventh in the table. The dreaded play-off spot. This team were having thoughts and aspirations of finishing in the top six only back in March. It’s been the all mightiest of arse collapses from the team to be in the position they are in now.
      Lastly, Paul Hartley was giving his marching orders on Monday to bring to an end his reign at Dundee which lasted three years, two months and twelve days.
      I wasn’t surprised by the decision. In fact, I felt that it maybe should have come after the 7-0 demolition we bent over and took at home from Aberdeen a few weeks ago. I was willing to live in hope that he could turn it around with the games remaining but Saturday put an end to that for me.
      The team looked disjointed. No one looked like they knew what the hell they were doing. Hateley was playing right wing back (even I never knew where he was supposed to be) and Cammy Kerr was shunted over to play on the left again.
      The body language along with the lack of effort, especially in the second half, from some players suggested to me that he had lost the dressing room.
      In all honesty, it was a sad end to Hartley’s Dundee managerial career that started with a win at home to Hamilton and then finished with defeat at home to Hamilton.
      Paul helped us over the finishing line to win the Championship in 2014 then in our first season, managed the team to a very unlikely top six finish. The following season, we missed out on finishing in the top six on the last day of the season despite having possibly three players (Scott Bain, Greg Stewart, Kane Hemmings) who were the best or close to for their position in the country.
      It was a massive disappointment to finish seventh that year and this was merely papered over by the Doon Derby where we relegated our neighbours on our own patch.
      This season has been a disaster. We flirted with the prospect of being safe this year with a top half finish but ultimately, we bottled it. I lost count of the chances we had to create gaps with the bottom clubs only to blow them. We then went on a record breaking six consecutive defeats only to go on and match that record and then beat it. All in the space of six months or so.
      So, with Hartley’s desk cleared, it was time to find an interim manager for the reminder of the season. Names such as Alex Neil, Jim Duffy, Alan Stubbs and even Fabrizio Ravanelli were banded about but our fate would be placed in the hand of Sky Sports Pundit and former Dundee hero, Neil McCann.
      It’s up there with some of the strangest appointments out there. It caught me off guard and I’ll hold my hands up and declare I was underwhelmed. You then remember that he knows Dundee from his two spells with us. He has seen the team play plenty of times this season and will know the players. There is no doubting that he will have been watching us in the past while wondering why this player was being played there, why we weren’t using a certain formation so the players could play to their strengths etc etc.
      It’s a massive gamble to bring him in for the final five games of the season for his first managerial job but then again, no matter who we brought in, it would have been a massive gamble considering the timescale.
      We need someone to come in and motivate the players. We need someone to come in with a passion for the club and to boot them right up the arse! We need someone to come in to play a simple formation that the players can all adjust to and feel comfortable with.
      Is McCann the man to do this?
      Well, we will find that out soon but one certainty is, he will have my full backing. He has just under two weeks to get in, make his mark on this team and get them back to picking up points. It’s not the most ideal situation to be in but it’s happening now and everyone from the fans to the players have to back each another.
      This starts next weekend at Motherwell, the scene of our best performance this season.
      More than ever, let’s get behind the team and MON THE DEE!