I think Goodwin would be a good choice when one weighs up what is out there. Macintyre had experience and look what happened. Goodwin is a young, hungry, ambitious manager who has done well with Alloa. When they appointed him I was not impressed which shows how wrong we can be. He is a no nonsense guy and if we get him to agree terms then I will be delighted. You never know when appointing manager's, down the line he might prove to be a dud, but at the moment he is a person whose star is on the rise and who is catching the attention of many within the game. Let's hope if he is the one that his star will continue to rise.