Hartley's Signings

[Cobra]

I should really have asked this last week but thought it would be interesting all the same to see the results.

[CC33]

BEST -  Bain , O`Dea and El Bak - still have high hopes for El Bak , i was torn between El Bak or O`Hara as my 3rd pick.

WORST - Klock - biggest reason was that it was a complete pointless signing. He is prob a better player overall than the likes of Duffy / Harris but i regard Kloc the worst as it was so pointless

 

[Mr Gandosaur]

Arturo has to be the worst considering the wages he was supposedly on. 

Schenk, Klok etc were all honking but would have been on buttons. 

[Cobra]

I went for the mid-season signings that transformed our three seasons in the top flight... the September arrival of Clarkson that rescued 2014/15, the January arrival of O'Dea that turned things around for us in 2015/16 and the October arrival of Haber that saved us this season.

The capture of Killie's under-appreciated full-back O'Hara was a stroke of genius that shouldn't be forgotten either.

[UWTB1893]

Best | O'Hara, O'Dea and Haber for me 
Worst | Arturo by a country mile if we were paying what I heard was a hefty fee of his wages.

[WeighorstsWang]

Best - Bain, Captain Thomo and O'Dea.

Worst - Schenk. Never a professional in a million years.

[Sebastiano Nela]

Best: GGH, Bain, O'Dea

Worst (of a honkin bunch) - Arturo - given the reported money he was being paid

[CC33]

God didnt realise Arturo was on good money - even more baffling by PH

[jack12895]

Bain, O'Dea and Haber. Make no mistake about it if Haber was never signed we would already be relegated.

Schenk's sole appearance speaks for itself.

[TC86]

How come Williams isn't listed as an option in the best signings list ?..

[clearwater]

25 minutes ago, DBDU said:

How come Williams isn't listed as an option in the best signings list ?..

Or Yordi as an option in the worst signing list

[Ivan Drago]

Schenk will always be seen as a joke figure but in reality he should have just been cover that never featured. 

When it comes to disappointments I would argue Ferry is also up there. I plumped for Harris as a winger who couldn't beat an egg isn't my cup of tea (apologies for the mixed breakfast related metaphor). Arturo and Klok were bizarre to say the least as well. 

For best I've gone Bain and O'Dea plus Thomson. I appreciate there were issues with Thomson and his injuries but I find it impossible to argue that we were not at our best with him in the side.