Bain Or Letheren?

[Ludo*1]

A debate that was ongoing on Mad the past few weeks and months. And with polling being my favourite new addition thought I'd create another one!

Provided both were fully fit, who should be our number 1?

[Psychedelic]

I voted Bain, feel really sorry for Letheren though, as he's not done anything to warrant getting dropped in particular. Bain has come in and done really well though, so difficult to look past him at the moment!

[BlueDee]

Bain to me has the making to be a great keeper. To think that he has over 100 competitive games on his hands already and he is only 22.

I can't see Letheren getting his spot back after he comes back from injury, unless Bain really screws up. I always thought Hartley wanted Bain as his number one anyway, but couldn't give him the shirt because Letheren was playing pretty well.

[skullduggery]

Bain is still a young lad and is by far the better keeper of the two. He will only get better.

[Double Blue]

I'd vote for Bain. He commands the box better than Lethern and is also better with crosses. One small negative point is the time he lies on the ground after a save trying to waste time. I hate it when opposition players do it and it could lead to an unecessary booking.

[TwaFFs]

While Bain is showing such prowess, Letheren will have to accept he's on the sidelines.

I would not want to lose him, but also encourage the younger keeper to get game time (especially when he's doing so well)

Overall, Bain has shown class, but only over time could anyone really say with proper commitment, who is the better keeper.ATM

, I reckon they're almost equal with Bain edging it and hopefully he can continue.

[IstanbulDee]

Bain for me. Looks to command his box far better and not frightened to move off his goal line.

His distribution looks superior, but that may just be me looking through Bain coloured glasses...

ID

[Ludo*1]

Didn't expect it to be so convincingly in favour for Bain so far!

[clearwater]

Bain every day of the week.

I'm afraid to say, but Kyle just doesn't command his penalty box.

Scott is streets ahead in this department, his distribution is excellent and is also a very good shot stopper. 

[TheDarkBlues]

Just like to say your forgot about our 3rd goal keeper! Arvid Schenk. Naughty boy Ludo!!

[Colinsdarius]

Bain for me as well, but I also feel sorry for Kyle. His save against Dumbarton is one of the most important saves of the last 20 years.

[dundeeman35]

Bain for me sorry kyle but we have stopped letting in headers since kyle got injured.