Dundee's Best Keeper Over The Last 40 Years

[TheDarkBlues]

Ludo's question about our current keepers got me thinking about our keepers over the last 40 years, and we have had some fine keepers dawning the Dundee shirt.

But who do think was our overall best keeper out of the selection?

edit: I added Michel Pageaud for Ludo

[clearwater]

Didn't have to think about that one.

Without a shadow of doubt - Thomson Allan

Followed by Rab Geddes n Rab Douglas.

[Randy]

I'm too young to have seen most of them. For me it's Speroni then Douglas.

[Sarah Machete]

For me it has to be Julian Speroni. #legend #vamos

[Randy]

Skip to 1:18

[Dayster]

Speroni here too....No old enough for any pre Mathers

[BROODEE]

What no Tom Carson? No Allen Blair?

[JDee]

Speroni for me, again not old enough to have seen past Langfield. 

[Prince Buster]

We've had some cracking keepers over the years - Broodee obviously taking the mick though

Thomson Allen for me, 5' 11" or something but what a keeper, one of the best crossers of a ball we ever had too.

[TheDarkBlues]

We've had some cracking keepers over the years - Broodee obviously taking the mick though

Thomson Allen for me, 5' 11" or something but what a keeper, one of the best crossers of a ball we ever had too.

This guy was my 'hero' when I was a kid. Inspired me a lot through my aspirations to be a keeper!

[TheDarkBlues]

What no Tom Carson? No Allen Blair?

Ok, will give you Carson..... Blair is going too far!!!

[Ludo*1]

Clearly the correct answer is Marco Roccati. Just had a quick scout of his wiki page and he retired at 33 after going round a host of lower league Italian teams.

Voted for Rab, if Michel Pageau was an option would have been sorely tempted to vote him! Although Speroni was probably better, it was much of a muchness.