Karl Madianga

[TheDarkBlues]

3 hours ago, Cobra said:

Hard to believe that Madianga went from being labelled "signing of the summer" in July/August to not being considered an option for our Scottish Cup game v Queens (despite us being desperately short of bodies) a few months later.

Madianga is a good player in my opinion, and I would like to see him given another chance as I believe JM wrote him off far too quickly (in much the same way McCann did with other players we had).

After the (first) Rangers game of this season, all my Zombie loving mates were raving about him and wanting them to sign him.

 

[Robert]

He's simply a player that doesn't give 100 % and his attitude is questionable to say the least. 

[TheDarkBlues]

1 minute ago, Hillbankdee said:

He's simply a player that doesn't give 100 % and his attitude is questionable to say the least. 

According to who?

[Bobby123]

52 minutes ago, Hillbankdee said:

He's simply a player that doesn't give 100 % and his attitude is questionable to say the least. 

Exactly right-has ability but cant be arsed tracking back,tackling,breaking play up- nudging the opposition ,giving aeay the odd foul

BASICALLY TOO SOFT FOR SCOTLAND- and the referees  we have

[chomp my root]

1 minute ago, Bobby123 said:

Exactly right-has ability but cant be arsed tracking back,tackling,breaking play up- nudging the opposition ,giving aeay the odd foul

BASICALLY TOO SOFT FOR SCOTLAND- and the referees  we have

Is it possible he could be coached ?

[Bobby123]

Who knows how to coach kicking a player-Glennie,Cammie Fraser,Jim Steele

No one nowadays

[WeighorstsWang]

3 minutes ago, Bobby123 said:

Exactly right-has ability but cant be arsed tracking back,tackling,breaking play up- nudging the opposition ,giving aeay the odd foul

Funny that, that reads exactly like Greg Stewart and Gary Harkins. Two players who are lauded and would apparently walk into this team. 

[Cobra]

1 minute ago, WeighorstsWang said:

Funny that, that reads exactly like Greg Stewart and Gary Harkins. Two players who are lauded and would apparently walk into this team. 

Stewart and Harkins frequently were condemned on here for "not putting in a shift". The minute they left though they were sorely missed and all the negativity about what they didn't do was quickly forgotten.

[Bobby123]

Disagree about Hatkins,gave 100% in viirtually every game I say him play

May have looked of the pace but I thought he gave what was in the tank

Where as I could not say that Madianga gave everything he had

Edited 16 January 2019 by Bobby123

[chomp my root]

3 minutes ago, Bobby123 said:

Disagree about Hatkins,gave 100% in viirtually every game I say him play

May have looked of the pace but I thought he gave what was in the tank

Where as I could not say that Madianga gave everything he had

What about Stewart ???

[Bobby123]

I dont think Stewart gave everything in his tank - with his ability he could have influenced more games but tended to drift in and out.

[chomp my root]

4 minutes ago, Bobby123 said:

I dont think Stewart gave everything in his tank - with his ability he could have influenced more games but tended to drift in and out.

Funnily enough Si Ferry was talking about Stewart on his latest podcast and said he needed to be left to do his thing as he basically wasn't athletic enough to give a balls out 90 minutes. Harkins was the same in my view, these guys brought something different and if they had both would be at a much higher level.