Rate the Ref: William Collum (Aberdeen - Home, 18th Aug 2019)

[TheDarkBlues]

The ref against Aberdeen was Bobby Madden . How did you rate his performance in this game?

[barkblue]

It was all in wrestling at times and Logan should have been booked prior to the yellow he was shown but by his standards that was a good game, so I voted average.  

[steven dee]

20 minutes ago, barkblue said:

It was all in wrestling at times and Logan should have been booked prior to the yellow he was shown but by his standards that was a good game, so I voted average.  

I didn't think he was as bad as a lot of other Dundee fans did. Like yourself  I thought his only major error was not booking Logan for a terrible tackle 10 mins before he did finally book him. Would have to see the first penalty shout again though.. 

[Cobra]

Astonishing decision to not book Logan. If stopping an attack by taking out an opposition player isn't a booking, I have no idea what is.

[WoodStein]

On 17/03/2019 at 14:06, TheDarkBlues said:

The ref against Aberdeen was Bobby Madden . How did you rate his performance in this game?

Another ref with 'multiple personality disorder', eh....  .....started off the match as Wullie Collum, then morphed intae Bobby Madden (wi' hair) by second half....I also heard the commentator mention Dallas, so either that wiz his 3rd personality for the ET, or maybe JR was watching?

[Donny O]

A stonewall handball penalty, A blatant Push in the Box, another wrestling match in the Box and failing to give that Logan guy a straight red for that leg breaker tackle!!!Both Linesmen were terrible too!!!!

[sneddee]

logan should have been off!! the ref was biased towards them.