Jump to content
The Dark Blues
This forum is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.

McPake Poll

Rate this topic


Should McPake stay on and be given more time to prove himself as the Dee Manager?  

136 members have voted

  1. 1. Should McPake stay on and be given more time to prove himself as the Dee Manager?



Recommended Posts

  • Administrator

Not creating this poll as a means to beat our manager with, just looking to get where our support stand with our manager at the moment.

Link to post
Share on other sites
This forum is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.
  • Replies 202
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Mate go to Dens and speak to guys who go  week in week out... guys that won’t renew there season tickets next season as they have had enough guys that will sit in the pub in Arbroath ne

Worst display ive seen since the Kearno  Disaster!!!

I find it incredible that anyone would be happy to see McPake get more time - we have Arbroath and Dunfermline coming up, two sides that are better organised than we are and that can score goals, both

Out of his depth I'm afraid, has a team of decent players and is failing week on week to get the best out of them, at this rate we will not be in the play offs, as much as it hurts we need the like of a John Robertson, I would even consider the likes of Barry Smith to do a better job.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

I couldn't believe it when Finlay was injured and he picked Moore as the guy to bring on over Byrne. I get that it's not easy being forced into a sub but we had an experienced option there with some presence and he goes for the youngster - baffling.

When you're in this league, you get tough games where things maybe don't go to plan and you need to interact with it through the game. I'm unconvinced he is capable of doing that, the way he sulked about and avoided talking to any of the players during the long injury stoppage was telling for me.

I really think we're just prolonging the inevitable right now. I don't mind taking a punt on a promising young manager but we've thrown a guy with zero official first team coaching experience (and only more than a year in football) and invested a lot into that.

Keeping him is gambling that in a year or two, things click into place and he develops. I get our previous strategy hasn't gone the best but at least Hartley, when he got the chance to build a side, had years of actual experience at some level. McCann and McPake have been massive risks.

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, harry94 said:

I couldn't believe it when Finlay was injured and he picked Moore as the guy to bring on over Byrne. I get that it's not easy being forced into a sub but we had an experienced option there with some presence and he goes for the youngster - baffling.

When you're in this league, you get tough games where things maybe don't go to plan and you need to interact with it through the game. I'm unconvinced he is capable of doing that, the way he sulked about and avoided talking to any of the players during the long injury stoppage was telling for me.

I really think we're just prolonging the inevitable right now. I don't mind taking a punt on a promising young manager but we've thrown a guy with zero official first team coaching experience (and only more than a year in football) and invested a lot into that.

Keeping him is gambling that in a year or two, things click into place and he develops. I get our previous strategy hasn't gone the best but at least Hartley, when he got the chance to build a side, had years of actual experience at some level. McCann and McPake have been massive risks.

He has to go now to give us a chance of achieving a play off place. The players don't believe in him and the fans are after his hide.  McPake was a much bigger  risk than McCann, if only because of the failure of McCann. McPake is schooled in the same gutless slow style. The bigger worry is who we would get as a replacement. McPake doesn't seem to learn and Nelms doesn't either. Please not Barry Smith. Great clubman but failure as a manager.

Edited by Parcbara
  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, harry94 said:

I couldn't believe it when Finlay was injured and he picked Moore as the guy to bring on over Byrne. I get that it's not easy being forced into a sub but we had an experienced option there with some presence and he goes for the youngster - baffling.

It's just terrible man management, similar to dropping Kerr for Meekings last week. He must have fallen out with Byrne, no idea where Gowser was but wouldn't be surprised if he told him a few home truths! He has to go.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Administrator
34 minutes ago, gblue said:

should have voted No can you change TDB cheers

You can reselect your vote, there is a button to take you back to the poll options.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Administrator
8 minutes ago, J_Kitamirike said:

Either way.... he's going 

I cannot imagine that McPake would walk away nor can I see the Board sacking him for the time being. I believe he will be given to the end of the season and time to turn things around.

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Parcbara said:

He has to go now to give us a chance of achieving a play off place. The players don't believe in him and the fans are after his hide.  McPake was a much bigger  risk than McCann, if only because of the failure of McCann. McPake is schooled in the same gutless slow style. The bigger worry is who we would get as a replacement. McPake doesn't seem to learn and Nelms doesn't either. Please not Barry Smith. Great clubman but failure as a manager.

I agree not Barry in the longer term but if he got the job on an intermediary basis now, I would cheer from the rooftops.

JM has no idea what he is doing and the players are not trying.

Its a toxic mix.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Administrator
1 minute ago, Spiritof62 said:

I agree not Barry in the longer term but if he got the job on an intermediary basis now, I would cheer from the rooftops.

JM has no idea what he is doing and the players are not trying.

Its a toxic mix.

The only person I want to see take over would be Strachan from our staff.

I cannot see things changing any time soon, so as long as McPake is our manager he will get my backing, but he needs to start learning from his mistakes quickly.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, TheDarkBlues said:

The only person I want to see take over would be Strachan from our staff.

I cannot see things changing any time soon, so as long as McPake is our manager he will get my backing, but he needs to start learning from his mistakes quickly.

He wont learn. Hes the exact 50/50 mix of McCann and McIntyre. This is the beginning of a 8-9 match losing streak, mark my words. 

Edited by ThelegendthatisBeto
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
This forum is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.
  • This forum is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


This forum is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


  • Similar Content

    • By UWTB1893
      The Dark Blues fell behind early on when but quickly managed to get back on level terms. The first half was an entertaining affair with Dundee having the best chances to put themselves into the lead but the tempo whittled down during the second 45, with Dundee failing to cause any real threat except from a Graham Dorrans free-kick.

      Queens looked more dangerous on the break as Dundee found themselves in familiar territory of being unable to break down the opposition defence.

      Post Match, James McPake spoke of his frustration after another uneventful evening for his strikers and ultimately, another match without a victory.

      “It’s another missed opportunity and another game where the main problem was in the final third.

      “The frustration is we’re just not winning enough games, whether it’s home or away. That has to turn.
      “I’m picking positives so I don’t sound like a broken record – there was a lot of character shown after going a goal down. We then controlled the game.
      “We need to be better at the top end and that’s where my frustration lies tonight.
      “It was similar last week. We had chances to win. It’s a point but for me it’s two points dropped.
      “We know it will turn. We’re back at home next week and we need to be ready for it.”
    • By UWTB1893
      After declaring his interest in bringing his old teammate to Dundee last week, it seemed all had gone quiet on that front but McPake has managed to get the deal over the line and Dorrans will now be in tomorrows squad for our visit to Greenock to take on Morton.

      The ex-Scotland international has had to endure an injury ravaged Rangers career but will no doubt see this as the ideal opportunity to kick-start his career.

      There was rumoured to be interest from other Premiership clubs along with some interest from England but McPake has got his man and the fans will be hoping this move gives the team that vital creative spark that seems to have been missing.
    • By UWTB1893
      The Dundee manager was full of praise for the free-agent but did mention that any potential deal would have to be within budget.

      Dundee’s owner Tim Keyes today did however say in an interview with The Courier today that they “increased the budget a little” to bring in Kane Hemmings and that “the budget is always fixed but flexible,” so It may give McPake some hope that a deal can be struck to add Dorrans into his squad.

      “When a player like that pops up you'd be mad not to try and have a look at it," McPake said.
      "Would I like him? Absolutely, but I'm also very aware of the budget the board have already given me.
      "Graham will have a lot of options. I like him as a person, as a footballer. We've spoken about a lot of stuff but not money. If I had a chance to bring him here within budget and make it work then I would.
      "When I got the job, I jokingly said to him over a beer and a bite to eat 'I'm going to get you to Dundee' - I don't know if it's an option now or not.”
      "There's a hunger there, and a frustration from the last two years that his boyhood club hasn't worked out for him, but that's completely down to injury.
      "I know he's desperate to play football. He feels he's in good condition. He's had a real bad time of it with his knee.
      "He is looking to play football at a place he can reignite his career - he is far from finished and will be a good addition for someone."
    • By UWTB1893
      The talk before the match was all about returning hero Kane Hemmings, who found himself put straight into the starting XI but this meant Andrew Nelson was the unlucky forward to drop to the bench with Danny Johnson favoured to partner Hemmings up top.

      With the match still at 0-0 and Dundee struggling to find a way to break down a stubborn Ayr back-line, McPake replaced Johnson with Nelson and the substitute only took six minute to put the Dee ahead with a glancing header from a pin-point Jordan Marshall cross.

      McPake said: “Andy probably feels hard done by.

      “I had a front two that didn’t include him and that's no reflection on Andy who's had a good pre-season.

      “It was a tough decision to leave him out but that's football for you.

      “But I really love working with Andy. You get everything from him and he showed that again for how long he was on the park here.

      “His goal was great, a brilliant header. There’s so much more to come from him. We know he can make a massive contribution with goals allied to his overall play.

      “We’re just delighted to get off the mark. It was a tough, tough game. Ayr are a very dangerous side.

      “We’re going to need this grit and determination. We’re going to have a lot of teams coming to Dens and trying to frustrate us, and I felt we handled that well.”
    • By UWTB1893
      Paul Hartley was the man who brought McPake to Dens Park in the summer of 2014 as he prepared the Dee for their Premiership arrival but now, he will face off against his old gaffer as Dundee hope to build on Saturdays 3-0 victory over Raith Rovers.
      Despite now being managerial rivals, McPake is thankful that recently appointed Cove Rangers boss Hartley helped him get started on the road with coaching.
      “I liked the way he worked. He was unfortunate here, I think," said McPake.
      “The second season we finished seventh in the league and we were probably better than what we were the season before when we finished sixth. He had us going well here and it was unfortunate the way it ended, but he’s someone I really liked.
      “I was grateful. He was the one who got me into coaching. Well, not got me in, but gave me a head start. If Paul hadn’t done that then I wouldn’t be sitting here, that’s for sure. Knowing Paul, he wants to work and he takes on projects.
      “He’ll want to get them up through the leagues. That’s what will motivate him. He’s a hard worker and he will do well there.”
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.