The Window

[Smiffy1]

• vontae daley-campbell (highly rated)

•mcginn (proven)

• Rudden (highly rated)

• Chapman (no idea)

•Rossi (6ft 4" CB - crewe and hearts wanted)

 

See what happens with sparky and snoddy.

 

Not too shabby, but agendas will agenda.

[Derry Drummer]

2 minutes ago, Smiffy1 said:

• vontae daley-campbell (highly rated)

•mcginn (proven)

• Rudden (highly rated)

• Chapman (no idea)

•Rossi (6ft 4" CB - crewe and hearts wanted)

 

See what happens with sparky and snoddy.

 

Not too shabby, but agendas will agenda.

I don't think the signings are that bad mate but the way we have waited isn't the best. 

[dblair]

IF we get the center half in today i will be a bit happier, however our glaring problem has been at left back for me especially with Marshall injured.

[Dundeefc1783]

8 minutes ago, Smiffy1 said:

• vontae daley-campbell (highly rated)

•mcginn (proven)

• Rudden (highly rated)

• Chapman (no idea)

•Rossi (6ft 4" CB - crewe and hearts wanted)

 

See what happens with sparky and snoddy.

 

Not too shabby, but agendas will agenda.

So because people have a difference of opinion from you they have an agenda. People are just rightly pointing out what a mess this club is in. 

I personally think it has been a shambolic window for McPake but would you expect anything else. 

Our defence is woefully inadequate and to rectify that he has signed a young guy with zero experience for a relegation fight. This isn't the time for someone to be learning on the job imo. 

 

[Mr Sensible]

16 minutes ago, dblair said:

IF we get the center half in today i will be a bit happier, however our glaring problem has been at left back for me especially with Marshall injured.

Marshall meant to be available tonight

[offshoredee]

Marshall and McGhee fit seemingly 

 

[dblair]

Good news!

[Taipei]

Shambles of a window, yet again. 

Lost Cummings, Griffiths & Jakubiak and replaced them with one player who hasn’t played at this level. 

Signed an old winger who hasn’t scored in 18 months, and gave him an 18 month deal at the retirement home. 

RB could be a good player, but it’s one of the last positions that we required. Hopefully he is a good player. 

Maybe signed a defender who was last a regular when Killie were humped by us, very much a last minute desperate signing  

Canadian midfielder could be decent, have to wait and see. 

If it improves the team then great, but yet again, we exit a window and it doesn’t look very good. It’s only McPakes sixth window though, so he will get one right eventually. 

[Napper]

I suppose time will tell.. but, three strikers out, and so far, one in... we had two right backs at the club, so we get another in.. meanwhile, if Marshal gets injured, we have to play someone out of position to cover. I hope we get the centre back in..I imagine tonight will be too soon to play many of yesterday's signings from the get go.. so, basically we will be facing the dabs with the side that hasn't won in six league games... perfect.

[an-dee]

36 minutes ago, offshoredee said:

Marshall and McGhee fit seemingly 

 

I'd be starting them both if they are. 

[an-dee]

If the CH does sign it goes from an absolute shambles of a window to just a borderline acceptable/bare minimum window for me. I don't really think you can dress it up any other way to be honest. 

[bjs]

1 hour ago, Smiffy1 said:

• vontae daley-campbell (highly rated)

•mcginn (proven)

• Rudden (highly rated)

• Chapman (no idea)

•Rossi (6ft 4" CB - crewe and hearts wanted)

 

See what happens with sparky and snoddy.

 

Not too shabby, but agendas will agenda.

I’ve no agenda. I’ve backed McPake right up until the game after we came back from the winter shutdown but I’m also a realist. Everyone is entitled to there own opinion but I cannot fathom how anyone thinks that’s been a successful window. You actually say it yourself, McGinn is the only proven signing who is 100% better than who he’s replaced McCowan in the starting eleven and Jakubiak in the squad). The rest might have promise, might be highly rated elsewhere or we have no clue but the bottom line is for the others outside of McGinn we are crossing every finger and toe and praying!!

We still have no fit left footed full back, as of now we still only have two fit centre half’s and we are extremely short of strikers and creative attacking midfielders. I really hope they all hit the ground running and get of to a flier tonight but it’s not filling me with confidence at the moment!!!