Rate The Ref Rate The Ref: S.McLean (Dundee United, Home, 02nd Jan 2025)

[TAYZURRI]

The ref against Dundee United was S.McLean. How did you rate S.McLean performance in this match?

[Dundeefc1783]

Thought he was poor. 

So many fouls went unpunished then Graham got booked for an identical foul that Sevelj got away with 2 minutes earlier. 

And don't even get me started on him pulling us back when we had a 3 v 3 

[Prince Buster]

Absolutely diabolical. How Docherty stayed on the park is a total mystery, Mo was fouled every time he got the ball but got very little from him then he blew up when we had a 3 on 2 in attack.

He should never be allowed to referee a Dundee derby again.

[an-dee]

He was awful. Pulling it back when we had a two on one to give us a free kick in our own half is up there with the worst I’ve seen. How many professional fouls did they get away with in the middle of the park? One booking for them the whole match and Graham ends up booked for something they’d been doing the whole match?

[Indeed]

So many dab fouls, half were on Sylla. Someone suggested Sylla wasted too many balls. Maybe he did - between picking himself up after another dab foul.

Did the ref realise Utd  players can be booked also?

So many dabs were free to do what they wanted without fear of a booking. 

[GordonDee]

How Sevelj never got booked was unbelievable, multiple fouls DAB

[OCDee]

Terrible throughout but the refusal to allow that advantage was inexcusable.

[gblue]

Cameron and Mo were butchered and ref did nothing 

[BlueDragon]

Did not protect Cameron or Mo whole game pathetic

[Dondeh]

4 minutes ago, gblue said:

Cameron and Mo were butchered and ref did nothing 

We are way down the league compared to most teams in terms of fouls committed . Today was no exception. 

Fouls Committed 24/25 Season As at 30/12/24

St.Mirren 248

Hibs 232

Hearts 230

Dundee Utd 221

St.Johnstone 221

Aberdeen 220

Rangers 210

Motherwell 210

Kilmarnock 208

Ross County 206

Dundee 190

Celtic 171

[Valentke]

Add their winner started from Seb making a great tackle which was clearly our throw…..

There was obviously a no booking rule if you foul Lyall 

[Donny O]

Bar the penalty which he initially did not give!!.."Wore the opposition shirt" would have been the best option....Special mention to The Derry side lino who also gave us nothing the whole game and contributed at least once to "Them" putting us under pressure and indeed conceding!!!Very poor officials and certainly favoured "Them"