rate the ref Rate The Ref: Alan Muir (Vs. Aberdeen 22 Jan 2016)

[TheDarkBlues]

Rate the Ref, we have good ref's, bad ref's and we have Bob Valentine. After each game you guys can give your thoughts and rate the ref according to how well you thought they handled the game and how professional they were.

This weeks ref is: Euan Anderson.

[CW 90+3 02/05/16]

Not a great deal for him to do other than Logan's high foot on Holt and as I said on the other thread, thought Harkins could have had a penalty for shot blocked by arm.

[Cobra]

Voted average and fair but I think a player sticking his foot six high into a challenge without taking care to prevent a serious injury is considered unacceptable in the modern game. Should have been a red.

Edited 22 January 2016 by Cobra

[Blue4evr]

Credit to PH for saying in was accidental. If that had been McInnes he'd have been demanding a red.

[Cobra]

Credit to PH for saying in was accidental. If that had been McInnes he'd have been demanding a red.

Don't think intent matters. It was reckless and dangerous.

[Fas]

It was a red all day long. His "standing foot" was a foot off the ground and his other foot was studs up. His intent means SFA. 

Not a nasty challenge just unfortunate, still a red!

Apart from that the ref was good I thought.

[Boba Fett]

Poor officiating all round for me.. Ref and linesman made a lot of mistakes and the ref showed no consistency with his decisions either.

The linesman on our side was shocking, missed some clear offsides and was continually well behind play.