Jump to content

Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.

Recommended Posts

Posted

For me -

Bain - 9 - some great saves particularly first half. Busy night.

McGinn 5 - Our full backs don't stop much and are anon quite often defensively.

Konrad 4 - All over the place

O'Dea 5 - Bit better than Konrad

Holt 5 - Our full backs don't stop much and are anon quite often defensively.

Ross 5 - Effort was there but not on the ball much.

Low 4 - Too weak at key moments.

McGowan 5 - Dwells on the ball too much but effort there as always.

Harkins 6 - Couple of unfortunate slips but looked dangerous first half.

Hemmings 5 - Dangerous first half, very quiet second half.

Stewart 5 - Very quiet for large spells. Had a couple of good moments first half.

Kerr 9 - Best defender tonight. Commentators raving about him. Well done.

Loy 3 - Very quiet but we weren't really an attacking force by the time he came on.

Or am i being harsh?

Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.
  • Replies 3
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Think you are being just a tad harsh on some of them there PRD.

Bain - 9 - some great saves particularly first half. Busy night.  Agree with Sutton that he should have been coming for these close crosses more often.

McGinn 6 - An average game for him both defensively and going forward.

Konrad 4 - All over the place.  Couldn't cope and he knew it I think.

O'Dea 6 - Decent organiser.  Needs a dominating CH alongside him

Holt 5 - Needs to learn how to defend.  I get the impression he is actually thinking about his attacking duties before defending

Ross 4 - Of all the outfield players on the park, from both sides, he was the poorest by some way.  Good footballer but not in that position.

Low 5 - Started off well but faded.  Too weak at key moments.  Too easily pushed off the ball.

McGowan 6 - Put in another good shift but does tend to dwell on the ball a bit. Effort is always there.

Harkins 7 - Always looked our most dangerous player and the player capable of opening up their defence.

Hemmings 6 - Dangerous first half, very quiet second half.  I would have brought Loy on for him and Wighton for Low.

Stewart 5 - Very quiet for large spells. Had a couple of good moments first half.  Was well marked with three players around him at times.

Kerr 8 - Don't think he put a foot wrong in his time on the park.  Had he played like that for 90 minutes he would have got 10.

Loy 5 - Didn't get many touches or a real chance to show what he can do..

Posted

It wasn't Hamilton or the filth we played last night this was an Aberdeen team who are unbeaten in 10 league games and 3 points behind the league leaders for a reason.

Bain 8. 1 Great save the rest were saves id expect a keeper to make.

McGinn 7. Caught out for the goal again on a ball that's been switched from the opposite side of the park. Other than the goal thought he defended well against a good player in Naill McGinn.

Holt 7. Improving defensively. Done away fine against a very good player in Johnny Hayes until his injury.

Konrad 4. The weak link last night. Slow to close down and poor decision making. Simply not good enough against a top 6 side.

O'Dea 7. Very good organiser and totally nullified the ex dayglo thing.

Stewart 6. Quiet night for Greg. Should've scored when played in by GGH but poor touch let him down.

Ross 6. Neat and tidy but not what's required in the centre of midfield. Someone who can put the foot in and protect the back 4 is what we need. Looking for him to make runs into the box but never happens.

McGowan 7. Pick of the midfield 4 last night. Got on the ball and helped those around him defensively.

Low 6. 2 crucial moments decided his night. Done really well to win the ball from Logan but shouldn't found Harkins with his cross and should've put his foot through the ball with his chance in the 2nd half instead of trying to lob the keeper. Don't get the time he was looking for at that chance. Helped Holt and Kerr defensively. Fell out the game and lost or shape when replaced by Loy.

Harkins 7. Another good performance from him. Held the ball up well, looked dangerous and brought others into play.

Hemmings 8. Led the line well and gave their big centrehalf's a tough time.

Kerr 6. Done away fine defensively but gave the ball away time and again which frustrated his team mates around him. A bit more composure on the ball is required (which I'm sure will come) and look to find a teammate with the ball on the ground instead of an aimless punt up the park. Not a 1st choice left back but more than capable back up. Takes Irvine's place in the squad from now on.

Loy 4. Fell out the game when he came on. Would've replaced him for Stewart.

Edited by Pablothedee
Posted

Bain - 8 - some great saves particularly first half. He needs to start coming for more crossed balls.

McGinn 6 - did ok but must work on defensive side of game. Not helped by Stewart who doesn't track back much

Konrad 4 - poor game from him, one calamity after another. Needs to improve quickly

O'Dea 5 - not a great game from him either, made some silly mistakes. Never won much in the air. Must improve

Holt 5 - poor game again, Hayes has the beating of him every time we play them

Ross 5 - tired hard but did not influence the game at all

Low 4 - Too ligh weight but does have try 100%.

McGowan 5 - must move the ball quicker, runs into trouble. No much influence

Harkins 6- first half was decent but not much happened in the 2 half

Hemmings 6 - better in the first half, tban the second half. Can't seem to hold the ball up and his first touch was atrocious.

Stewart 4- poor performance tonight. Doesn't hardly track back to help defence. Loses the ball and doesn't chase the man who took the ball from him. Lazy and lethargic

Kerr 9 - should be strating before Holt. Well done young man.

Loy - not fair to mark him as we didn't push forward to even give him a chance to do anything

HARTLEY 4 -does not have the beating of McInnes regarding tactics. We are slow and show no urgency. He must sign a big strong CH and CM if this team is to improve

Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.

Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


Adblocker Detected

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.
×
×
  • Create New...