Rory Loy

[offshoredee]

Square peg in a round hole. Not his fault, his effort can't be faulted but it's not his position.

Young Cammy deserves s run now, maybe give the much maligned Holt a bit of much needed protection.

[Dundeefc1783]

Is that just a not so square peg in still round hole though?

[Pablothedee]

For the harder games this season Nicky Low's probably the best solution to play the wide left role.

Edited 6 March 2016 by Pablothedee

[offshoredee]

Maybe, but I think it needs to happen, even Low would be an option

[CC33]

he`s no as good a player as folk think imo.

however not fair on him being played out position , daft fi PH playing strikers as wingers , he never learns from these mistakes.

Why Kerr hasnt been playing is beyond me - shocking actually

[Dundeefc1783]

CC out of interest we have been on a good run up until yesterday, I'm sure even you would agree with that. So who would you have dropped for Kerr to play

[Pablothedee]

The formation we were playing up until the New Year derby wasn't really working but Loy was playing well. Rightly or wrongly I think Hartley's trying to fit him into the side because of this.

[CC33]

CC out of interest we have been on a good run up until yesterday, I'm sure even you would agree with that. So who would you have dropped for Kerr to play

Id drop either full back for Kerr esp Holt

Id play either Kerr or Wighton instead of Loy out wide

[Dundeefc1783]

I agree with you re holt needing dropping but again we would just be playing players out of position.

Is Meggatt fit yet? Think he should be given a go at left back since it is his natural position. He can't be worse than Holt.

I don't think Wighton has the work ethic to play left midfield from what I have seen so far.

Left side is defo a problem area that needs sorted in the summer.

[Cobra]

CC out of interest we have been on a good run up until yesterday, I'm sure even you would agree with that. So who would you have dropped for Kerr to play

We haven't scored in our last five away games now. We've only won one away game since September. That was at Partick and Loy was on the bench. 

If we were going to get a result at Ibrox I think Low or Kerr had to start instead of Loy. Hartley prides himself on 'having a go' but playing too many attackers just isn't working for us away from Dens. 

[Dundeefc1783]

Cammy Kerr is a good young player with bags of potential but why do Dundee fans seem to think he can play just about any position on the park?

[chomp my root]

I agree with you re holt needing dropping but again we would just be playing players out of position.

Is Meggatt fit yet? Think he should be given a go at left back since it is his natural position. He can't be worse than Holt.

I don't think Wighton has the work ethic to play left midfield from what I have seen so far.

Left side is defo a problem area that needs sorted in the summer.

Meggatt was on the bench yesterday so an option.

Cammy Kerr is a good young player with bags of potential but why do Dundee fans seem to think he can play just about any position on the park?

Yeah, I'm sure Cammy would play in goal if he was asked but we seem desperate to plonk him in any position and think he'll be the answer. He's a right back and a right mid and I'd rather see him playing there than on the left unless it was emergency cover.